So there are a lot of preconceived notions when it come to a record like this.
A covers album. Sounds like a weak idea but when I really think about it, I enjoy covers albums. I liked Anthems by Anthrax and Feedback by Rush was pretty fun as well, just to name two. I was disappointed when I initially heard about the project, because I felt the song choices were obvious. Who needs to hear Whole Lotta Love or Break On Through more than we already do?
Nevertheless, the cast of characters is so vast and dazzling that you can’t help but start to get curious….Christopher Lee, Bob Ezrin, Dennis Dunaway, Neal Smith, Brian Johnson! Robby Krieger! Zak Starkey! Slash, Joe Perry, Johnny Depp (he's actually a good guitar player), Joe Walsh, Paul McCartney not to mention Alice Cooper!....holy cow! (sigh...ok….it also has Dave Grohl on it, big deal).
The record arrives in the mail, I open it. It’s a handsome gatefold. But...I can’t help but wish that the sleeve itself were made more to look like the book of the Hollywood Vampires complete with embossed cover, rather than just being a photograph of a book. Would have been that much cooler. Images-wise, it’s also very sparse.
Let’s jump right into the music, shall we?
Side A
The Last Vampire
Well, the cavernous barritone of Christopher Lee is a very worthy successor to the brilliant Vincent Price from way back in 1975. Only I’ve heard the story he tells here a few times now and I still can never quite follow it. But I have trouble following lyrics in general. He sure sounds cool, though.
Raise The Dead
So this is the new Coop. An original song, it sure is robust and leaping out the speakers. Alice isn’t back, he never left. He manages to always sound contemporary and this is no different. It’s blazing rock but somehow feels very modern and energetic. The concept, of course is that by celebrating the songs of fallen Hollywood Vampires we are, in effect, raising the actual dead. A pretty neat concept that also fits right into the Alice Cooper ethos. It’s a pretty kickass song.
My Generation
The guest list is partly the fun of listening to each track. So here, let’s get our groove on listening to Zak Starkey, Ringo’s son. He is the embodiment of Keith Moon (stylistically) when he tours with the two-Who, and so it is fitting that he is on hand to be Moonie on record. Still, this cover is certainly fine in every detail, but my gut tells me it’s a little too spot on. It sounds like a studied replication, and so somewhat pointless.
Whole Lotta Love
This was the one song I’d heard prior to release and I was impressed. Because it goes new places. It’s edgy and experimental, it rocks and it’s fun to listen to guest Brian Johnson screeching outside of AC/DC. And that’s the Coop himself doing Page on the harmonica, in one of the interesting twists on the original.
What you can take away from Side A is that this supergroup, the Hollywood Vampires, the backbone of which is Alice on vocals, Johnny Depp & Tommy Henriksen on guitars, Bruce Witken on bass and a rotating cast of drummers is that this is a hard-charging, forward-thinking "band".
Side B
I Got A Line On You
Waitaminnit...Didn’t Alice cover this song already? Why do the same one again especially when Spirit have countless great songs. This one is not among my favorites on this. It is high energy and very (ahem) spirited. But it oozes out a little too polished for my tastes.
Five To One/Break On Through
Robby Krieger himself plays guitar here, so right away I’m intrigued. Five To One has a nice swampy stomp to it, although they stick pretty closely to the original recipe and then segue into Break On Through. And this was a mistake, if you ask me. The vocals in the chorus are weak and it ruins the whole piece for me. They don’t match the wild abandon and dark mysticism of the original. Vince himself never seems sure if he’s chanelling Alice or if he should stick with aping Morrison.
One/Jump Into The Fire
Alice’s version of One is the best thing I’ve heard from the Coop in a long time and the bitch is that they only tease you with it before segueing into the main piece Jump Into The Fire. Snaky, creepy and sexy, this is classic Coop straight out of the mid-70’s.
Even though I’m disappointed that they didn’t play the whole thing, this rendition of Jump Into The Fire is a lot of fun and has the same buoyant clamor of the original.
After the first platter, conspicuously absent from my thoughts and observations is Bob Ezrin. I can’t hear “him” per se. Maybe because we’re dealing with covers mainly, so his compositional stamp isn’t on the material as it usually was with Cooper’s material.
Side C
Come And Get It
I don’t really get why McCartney is on here other than they could get him? He wasn’t a vampire. There was a lot of death surrounding him and Badfinger. Ok, he gets a pass. Sill, seems off a little. The rendition itself is ok, sounds a little weightier and lumbering than the original. It’s not bad, but nothing special either.
Jeepster
Here’s a spot-on rendition that works! Alice channels Marc Bolan surprisingly well. Nice bright jangle to this one that recalls the jubilant yet romantic love affair Bolan had with Elvis and Chuck Berry’s brand of what essentially is hillbilly rock and roll.
Cold Turkey
This is the 2nd best track on the whole thing. Alice turning in a snarling peformance and paying homage to the original Lennon single, as elsewhere across the album, in a close facsimile. But it works here, indeed elevating the original by reminding us what a masterstroke of dark rock this was in the first place.
Manic Depression
Once again sticking to the original template, we nevertheless have another winner.
It’s interesting listening to Alice’s Hendrix impression, but it’s well sung and the tumbling instrumentation of the original bounces forth here in an equally raucous manner.
The album hits a peak on Side C with several great renditions and performances providing the standout tracks for this oeuvre.
Side D
Itchycoo Park
This plays with my mind. The parts are there but it sounds like some new, modern pop song. Do I think it’s great or cheesy? I’m worried that the cheese is a little too thick and studio polish has a little bit too much lustre.
School’s Out/Another Brick In The Wall part 2
I don’t deny this is a great song. But it’s overdone, and I don’t see the need for its inclusion here. Unfortunate because Neal and Dennis from the original gang are back here. But it’s a wasted effort. Pedestrian recreation with a less interesting production job and an out-of-place Brian Johnson guesting on vocals.
Melding this with Another Brick In The Wall part 2 is an interesting set piece during concerts, but doesn’t have any real reason to exist in a studio version.
My Dead Drunk Friends
I get it but I find it a bit long and cumbersome. Capped at a minute and a half with a fadeout, it would have been decent.
So what’s the verdict? Solid, fun effort that should have been cut down to a single piece o’ wax.